Interest Haiku #7: Weakness of Will
Tuesday, December 9th, 2003 01:40 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
flwydWeakness of Will -
I know what to do
Motivation not present
Incontinance sucks
I'm the only person with this interest, though a few people are interested in the Greek version, akrasia and several (mainly Christian?) users and communities are interested in self-control. Also related are willpower, and incontinence, though I doubt these people have the same thing in mind.
It's a subject that's familiar to most people, but it doesn't receive a lot of attention. Since at least Plato, philosophers have asked "Is knowledge sufficient for virtue?" That is, if a person knows that X is the right thing to do, will he do X? I think the answer is clearly "no," but it seems that most philosophers (Plato included) try to redefine "knowledge," "right," and so forth so that the answer is "yes," because that gives us higher hopes for our ethical theories.
Suppose you're on a diet. You know you shouldn't eat chocolate cake for dessert, and you tell your friends "I'm not going to have dessert." But then the waitress comes over and asks if she can get you anything else, and you blurt out "I'll have the chocolate cake." What's happened? Do you (momentarily) not believe that you shouldn't have chocolate cake? Doubtful. Did you talk yourself into thinking chocolate cake isn't fattening? (It's okay! I had Subway!) Maybe. Did one voice in your head say "I don't want any dessert" and another voice shouted "I want the chocolate cake!" and took over your executive function? This seems more likely. This is an example of weak will.
Weakness of will is a problem with lack of action as well. You're watching TV and Entertainment Tonight comes on and you say "I really should get up and do homework so I don't fail this class." But then you don't get up. You know you need to do homework. You know Entertainment Tonight is not a good use of your time. You don't even care about Michael Jackson. You're motivated not to fail, because then you'll have to retake the class. But you can't get your body lifted off the couch. This is another example of weak will.
Sophomore year I took a "Philosophy and Literature" course where this was the main topic of discussion. It was at 9:30 AM, so I didn't grok as many of the nuances as I'd have liked, but the issues stewed in my mind for a while. I wrote a one-act play which involved a guy and his shadow as separate characters. I'm a slacker, so I haven't posted it in the 3.5 years I've had available. Will do so soon, however. The next year, I took an "Ethics and Psychology" seminar and wrote a pretty good paper that I presented the next year at the Rocky Mountain Student Philosophy Conference. My argument was that we don't have a good framework for discussing (weakness of) will, so I drew some preliminary distinctions. For instance, it's important to distinguish actions based on the amount of conscious control we have over them. I used substance addiction as a recurring example, though I had trouble finding good research on substance abuse qua willpower. One cool thing about the paper was the meta-section, where I described my process of writing the paper while suffering from a lack of self-control.
I encourage my wonderful readers to post a comment describing a personal account of weak will (in haiku form, if you like). You can talk about a time when you knew what you should do but did something else. Or you can talk about a time when you knew what you should do but didn't do anything. Or you can talk about a time when you knew what you shouldn't do, but did it anyway.
I know what to do
Motivation not present
Incontinance sucks
I'm the only person with this interest, though a few people are interested in the Greek version, akrasia and several (mainly Christian?) users and communities are interested in self-control. Also related are willpower, and incontinence, though I doubt these people have the same thing in mind.
It's a subject that's familiar to most people, but it doesn't receive a lot of attention. Since at least Plato, philosophers have asked "Is knowledge sufficient for virtue?" That is, if a person knows that X is the right thing to do, will he do X? I think the answer is clearly "no," but it seems that most philosophers (Plato included) try to redefine "knowledge," "right," and so forth so that the answer is "yes," because that gives us higher hopes for our ethical theories.
Suppose you're on a diet. You know you shouldn't eat chocolate cake for dessert, and you tell your friends "I'm not going to have dessert." But then the waitress comes over and asks if she can get you anything else, and you blurt out "I'll have the chocolate cake." What's happened? Do you (momentarily) not believe that you shouldn't have chocolate cake? Doubtful. Did you talk yourself into thinking chocolate cake isn't fattening? (It's okay! I had Subway!) Maybe. Did one voice in your head say "I don't want any dessert" and another voice shouted "I want the chocolate cake!" and took over your executive function? This seems more likely. This is an example of weak will.
Weakness of will is a problem with lack of action as well. You're watching TV and Entertainment Tonight comes on and you say "I really should get up and do homework so I don't fail this class." But then you don't get up. You know you need to do homework. You know Entertainment Tonight is not a good use of your time. You don't even care about Michael Jackson. You're motivated not to fail, because then you'll have to retake the class. But you can't get your body lifted off the couch. This is another example of weak will.
Sophomore year I took a "Philosophy and Literature" course where this was the main topic of discussion. It was at 9:30 AM, so I didn't grok as many of the nuances as I'd have liked, but the issues stewed in my mind for a while. I wrote a one-act play which involved a guy and his shadow as separate characters. I'm a slacker, so I haven't posted it in the 3.5 years I've had available. Will do so soon, however. The next year, I took an "Ethics and Psychology" seminar and wrote a pretty good paper that I presented the next year at the Rocky Mountain Student Philosophy Conference. My argument was that we don't have a good framework for discussing (weakness of) will, so I drew some preliminary distinctions. For instance, it's important to distinguish actions based on the amount of conscious control we have over them. I used substance addiction as a recurring example, though I had trouble finding good research on substance abuse qua willpower. One cool thing about the paper was the meta-section, where I described my process of writing the paper while suffering from a lack of self-control.
I encourage my wonderful readers to post a comment describing a personal account of weak will (in haiku form, if you like). You can talk about a time when you knew what you should do but did something else. Or you can talk about a time when you knew what you should do but didn't do anything. Or you can talk about a time when you knew what you shouldn't do, but did it anyway.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2003-12-09 01:31 pm (UTC)Mind stewing brewing
Short term pleasure long term goal
Inaction beats brain
Umbrellas
Date: 2003-12-09 04:22 pm (UTC)An oasis in reverse
Some say 'bumberchute'
Re: Umbrellas
Date: 2003-12-10 12:13 am (UTC)... and your haiku, of course.
Re: Umbrellas
Date: 2003-12-10 04:23 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2003-12-09 04:23 pm (UTC)An Akratic Haiku
Final Projects: Three
Unbegun and due Thursday
Yet, still I LJ...
no subject
Date: 2003-12-09 06:49 pm (UTC)I have finals in two days.
Here I am instead.
I just want to add that it really frustrates me when people don't get the whole weakness-of-will thing. I've had friends whose response to "I just can't get motivated to go to the gym" was "Isn't wanting to get in shape enough motivation?" To which I replied something about short-term versus long-term motivation, but still wasn't sure if they had any clue what I was talking about.
no subject
Date: 2003-12-10 12:10 am (UTC)I like how, at least on my friend's page, the words of the last three lines all match up so I see "you can talk about a time..." 3 lines deep.
*ahem*
Time to leave, but wait!
The computer pulls me in.
I am an addict.
no subject
Date: 2003-12-10 02:25 am (UTC)Google for giner-sorolla and send me an email. I'll send you back a reading list for a lecture I gave, including one of my own publications.
shouldn't....
Date: 2003-12-10 02:13 pm (UTC)he lured me in with words true
what he said i knew
i dont really know if i'm talking about the same thing as you here, but what i hate most is the feeling after. because even if it isn't cheating on a partner you always feel cheated after. because you know that is was your weak will that allowed whatever to happen (ET over homework, chocolate cake over the diet) somehow somewhere you could have stopped what you did. but you didn't. you let it happen. you cheated yourself. (of course this intense... guilt?... is probably more intense when it's something like cheating on a partner)